Should we calculate the cost of performing an experiment on the ISS? Is there a fee chart available?
There is no need to calculate the cost of doing the experiment on the station. The ISS National Lab will provide transportation for the experiment to and from the ISS using our allocation from NASA.
Can we request funding from CASIS/ISS National Lab? What are the scopes and limitations for it?
Funding may be requested for an ISS flight project; however, please note that CASIS is not primarily a granting organization. While offerors may request funding for implementation of their flight project, please note that funds available for grants are limited and may not be provided. Offerors should plan to cover the cost of researcher time and materials. Costs of transportation to and from the space station are covered as part of the ISS National Lab Cooperative Agreement with NASA. Any grants awarded will be minimal and will depend on the number of meritorious applications received, the availability of funding or other resources for that solicitation’s open period, and programmatic priorities. No-cost and low-cost proposals will receive priority over higher-cost proposals when expected science return and feasibility are comparable. For Step 1: Concept Summaries, only an estimate for any budget is required.
For information on ISS National Lab Implementation Partners, see: www.issnationallab.org/implementation-partners
I am U.S. based and a U.S. citizen, is it acceptable to collaborate with a non-U.S. researcher?
As long as the offeror is listed as the Principal Investigator (PI) and their organization is the sponsoring U.S.-based entity submitting the proposal, it may be possible to include collaborators from outside the U.S. so long as they are not performing a leadership role on the project.
If a university or company decides to use a foreign national on its project, the ISS National Lab does not get involved in an entity’s export control program, particularly regarding ITAR and EAR. We rely on universities and companies to take all appropriate measures regarding export, including following appropriate NASA regulations. Offerors should confer with their export professionals for guidance.
NASA’s Export Control Program: https://oiir.hq.nasa.gov/nasaecp/
NASA Designated Countries: https://www.nasa.gov/oiir/export-control
Can you provide examples of successful applications as a guide?
CASIS cannot share prior submissions. Offerors should keep their ideas clear and answer the fields so we can best understand the concept, objectives, and outcomes of the proposal. The initial Step 1: Concept Summary submission is meant to be brief; more detail can be provided in the Step 2: Full Proposal phase.
Will you make available a list of submitters who are not selected?
We do not release information on offerors not selected for award.
The NLRA states the following, “Grant funding is not available for ground-based efforts” and “CASIS funding is to be allocated to support Implementation Partner costs only.”
If I read this correctly, there is no funding for our work in our lab, and only for the industry partner? Am I reading this correctly?
The NLRA statement on “ground-based efforts” means that we will not consider proposals for ground-based work only. A flight experiment that will use facilities on the space station must be proposed. Also, the allocation of CASIS funding is to cover costs for the Implementation Partner only (i.e., the “industry partner” referenced in the above question). Other costs such as for personnel in the offeror’s lab, fabrication, characterization, or sample preparation for the experiments would not be covered.
Does this program include a mission of astronauts as well?
For this NLRA, CASIS is unable to consider proposals that require testing to be performed on astronauts. Please review NASA’s website for opportunities that may be a better fit for such proposals.
The NLRA solicitation states that no proposals submitted by NASA and/or NASA civil servants will be accepted. Would a non-civil servant NASA contractor be eligible to submit a proposal as the PI, or does any connection to NASA deem a proposal ineligible?
A NASA contractor that is not a civil servant and not directly employed by NASA is eligible to submit a proposal as the PI, subject to the requirement that they are a U.S. person and affiliated with a U.S. entity.
- CONTRACTING AND COMPLIANCE
To be considered, proposals must be received from U.S. persons and U.S. entities as defined in the Code of Federal Regulations (CFR) and be compliant with ISS National Lab export control programs and policies.”
At what point in the process is the CASIS export control approval required? Where do we find the ISS National Lab export control programs and policies so that we can determine if we can satisfy them?
CASIS will perform an initial compliance review of submitted concept summaries at Step 1. Until export compliance has been confirmed, the concept cannot move forward in the process. CASIS follows the same export controls as NASA, and the export control programs and policies can be found on the NASA Export Control website: https://oiir.hq.nasa.gov/nasaecp/.
The CASIS MANDATORY FLOW-DOWN CLAUSES, GRANT AGREEMENTS states: “Restrictions on Certain Countries, Entities, and Persons; Export Control.
(i) Grantee and any subrecipient at any tier, including subcontractors and sub-awardees, shall not engage in any activities, including financial transactions, with a designated country (or entity or person therein) listed on NASA’s Designated Countries List without consultation and approval from NASA Export Control and the NASA Office of International and Interagency Relations (OIIR). Please reference NASA’s Designated Country List at the NASA Export Control Website https://oiir.hq.nasa.gov/nasaecp/. This list is regularly updated, therefore please consult the website to ensure use of the most up-to-date list. Grantee is required to follow the most current list of NASA’s Designated Countries.”
“Any activities” is very sweeping and exceeds normal export control regimens. This seems to prohibit even discussions of teaming. Is this the correct interpretation? How do you want this approval documented? Is this required before Step 1?
Conversations can be “deemed exports,” and it is up to the sponsoring organization’s export compliance department to determine if ITAR or EAR regulations require a license for those conversations to take place with non-U.S. persons. CASIS cannot determine whether any activities can be conducted prior to Step 1. Offerors should consult with their sponsoring entity’s export compliance department.
The List of NASA Designated Countries states “All Foreign National visitors require Center Export Administrator review and approval; in addition, Foreign National visitors to NASA born in or citizens of these countries require review and approval by an Agency International Desk Officer and the Headquarters Export Administrator. All NASA mail to these countries requires the concurrence of a NASA Center Export Administrator, in accordance with NPR 1450.10D, NASA correspondence Management and Communications Standards and Style, Appendix E. Foreign National Visitors who are currently citizens of, or born in, Countries Designated by an “X” in Column II will be denied, except in very particular circumstances.”
Does CASIS wish to be involved in our discussions with the identified NASA offices, and does it also wish to pre-approve email to the identified communities? How does CASIS wish us to document approval of every email?
CASIS need not be involved with the NASA export office. If NASA approval is granted, written approval should be provided to CASIS.
Would our sample materials be returned to Earth at any point in time, or would test results be gathered during orbit and retained onboard the ISS?
That is the offeror’s preference. The offeror can both gather data onboard and bring the experiment down for further analysis. Depending on the size of the experiment, it should be able to come down on the next available vehicle after testing.
Can you please clarify the funding cap for an individual project for NRLA 2022-5? I am confused as to how much is allotted for an Implementation Partner vs. a PI for this call.
CASIS funding is to be allocated toward Implementation Partner costs only, and all other cost items will be covered by the PI. No Implementation Partner funding cap has been set for an individual project.
What is the minimum TRL level mandatory prior to submission of this proposal?
As stated in the NLRA instructions, “proposed flight experiments should generally target raising the TRL from 4 or higher to 6 or higher.” These TRL numbers should be regarded as guidelines, not mandatory. An offeror’s technology or product should be beyond fundamental proof-of-concept and at the stage where testing in space is a key validation step along the pathway to commercialization. The proposal should support the stated starting and ending TRL.
Can a U.S. company, acting as Principal Investigator (PI) on a proposal, have a non-U.S. partner (specifically Canada)?
CASIS can only accept proposals from U.S. persons and U.S. entities. The PI may have a non-U.S. Person (unless the person is a citizen of a nation on the NASA designated countries list) on the team as a subcontractor or participant, but CASIS cannot directly contract with or award funding to a non-U.S. Person. The offeror has sole responsibility to ensure compliance with all applicable U.S. export regulations.
Are federally funded research and development centers (FFRDCs) eligible to apply to this NLRA?
FFRDCs are eligible to apply to this NLRA, provided NASA is not the FFRDC sponsor.
Can a non-immigrant act as PI for a proposal?
The PI on the proposal must be a U.S. Person as defined by U.S. export laws.
Can a PI submit multiple proposals in different emphasis areas?
Yes, a PI can submit multiple proposals, provided the emphasis areas and research topics are different for each proposal.
Is the goal of this NLRA to test and mature technologies for commercialization on Earth or to mature technologies for use on the ISS or on future missions? For the latter, it is hard to estimate “market share.”
The stated objective of the NLRA is to test and mature commercially viable technologies or products. Responding proposals should make the case for commercialization, including whether the application is focused on Earth or space, and how results from the work will provide tangible value for the offeror’s organization and to the nation.
Since CASIS is U.S. focused, can a proposed U.S. system be attached to Bartolomeo?
The Bartolomeo platform is operated by Airbus, an ISS National Lab Implementation Partner. Bartolomeo is available and can be used to host payloads sponsored by CASIS.
Are there established mass and volume restrictions for projects?
There are no established restrictions per se, but offerors should include that information in their Step 1: Concept Summary for evaluation of project feasibility. The CASIS Operations team (Ops@ISSNationalLab.org) can also provide basic guidelines and capabilities. The cargo resupply vehicles that launch to the ISS do have overall mass limits. CASIS is allocated approximately 500 kilograms total upmass for each mission of the current NASA CRS (Commercial Resupply Services) launch vehicles (i.e., SpaceX Dragon and Northrop Grumman Cygnus) for all ISS National Lab-sponsored projects. CASIS may encounter overall limitations, but there are typically no limitations on individual projects.
Historically, what are the most common hurdles to small businesses competing for these awards?
As manager of the ISS National Lab, part of the mission of CASIS is to provide access to the ISS for private companies, including small businesses, startups, and entrepreneurs. Other than the usual challenges associated with businesses in these categories (such as funding, team management and experience, innovative and commercially viable technologies and products, etc.) there are no special hurdles particular to small businesses that preclude their competing for an award under this NLRA. All proposals must meet the scope and criteria outlined in the NLRA application documents.
Are there any Intellectual Property guidelines or requirements within the CASIS program when working with Implementation Partners or the ISS National Lab?
Yes, there are several clauses in reference to Intellectual Property that are flow downs from NASA regarding Intellectual Property, rights, and data that are a required part of our contracting. Applicants should review the CASIS Terms and Conditions for standard agreements (www.issnationallab.org/user-agreements).
How are proposals viewed that involve launching a CubeSat from the ISS?
Proposals that involve CubeSat deployments from the ISS are within the scope of this NLRA.
Can you please explain the difference between funded and unfunded awards?
As stated in the NLRA instructions, “all awarded proposals will receive ISS National Lab sponsorship of ISS resource utilization, payload launch to the ISS, in-orbit ISS crew time, data return, and payload return, if required.” A funded award means that CASIS may award a portion of the $1M set-aside funding toward Implementation Partner costs. Unfunded means CASIS does not provide any funds toward Implementation Partner costs. Funded and unfunded awards also determine the nature of the agreements to be executed between CASIS and the PI’s organization.
What is the typical success rate for proposals in Step 1 and Step 2?
CASIS typically receives numerous Step 1 responses to its proposal requests, most of which do proceed to Step 2. Our expectation is to make up to four awards over the NLRA open periods.
When will applicants be notified whether or not they are invited to submit a Step 2: Full Proposal?
Responses will be provided to applicants within 2 weeks following CASIS receipt of a Step 1: Concept Summary. The Step 1 submission deadline is February 14, 2022. Applicants are encouraged to submit earlier to allow themselves more time for full proposal development.
Do you have preferences or constraints for the timeframe in which proposed hardware must be ready for launch? For example, what if one wanted to propose a project that would be ready to launch in 2023? Would a project that could be ready earlier be given preference?
CASIS communicates a preliminary launch timeframe and requirements after award and execution of agreements.
Is a project that would research materials for commercial space habitats, rather than an Earth application, eligible?
An applied research proposal targeting a commercial application in space may apply to this NLRA. All proposals must meet the criteria outlined in the instructions for this NLRA.
When will awards be announced, and when are you expecting to launch?
CASIS anticipates announcing awards within three months after Step 2: Full Proposal submissions close. Subject to flight vessel availability, a launch date depends primarily on the time required for payload integration. This time may vary from about nine months for simple experiments to 1.5 years for complex experiments.
Are there any examples of the proposal documents?
CASIS cannot share prior submissions. Proposal instructions are available on the NLRA website.
We have samples from a past space study. Can we ask for support to process and study assay samples to understand space biology?
The emphasis for this NLRA is on proposals for flight projects; however, data-use proposals that are responsive to the stated NLRA criteria will be considered. Please submit a Step 1: Concept Summary for a preliminary evaluation and response from CASIS.
For the Concept Summary, do you need a budget breakdown?
Yes, the Step1: Concept Summary template includes a budget table that must be completed with an estimate of project costs. The budget may be amended if the offeror are invited to submit a Step 2: Full Proposal. Please download the template from the NLRA webpage.
Can the ISS National Lab award a PI at JPL; are they eligible to receive research funds?
At present, no. As stated in NLRA 2022-5 for Technology Advancement and Applied Research, “Please note that CASIS will not accept or consider proposals submitted by NASA and/or NASA civil servants.” This exclusion pertains to the participation of NASA civil servants as PI and/or co-PI. NASA civil servants may serve on the support team of a project, but we are not permitted by our Cooperative Agreement with NASA to execute contracts with NASA field centers, including JPL as an FFRDC of NASA.
Which Implementation Partner or ISS National Lab facility possesses the resources and abilities for my project?
Please visit our Implementation Partner (IP) portal, where each IP presents an overview of their capabilities to enable a quick assessment of those that may best fit the needs of the project. CASIS follows a specific process for Implementation Partner selection by the PI after a Step 1: Concept Summary submission is approved. For ISS National Lab facilities, the ISS Researcher Guide Series is a useful starting point, with a more detailed listing available at the Space Station Research Explorer website.
If funds are for Implementation Partners, should we refer to them for budget items? The concept summary budget section is pretty minimal. Not the case for the actual proposal.
The Step 1 budget section is intended to provide a high-level, nonbinding overview of the project budget. For offerors who are new to ISS National Lab research, we recommend a preliminary discussion with at least one Implementation Partner to get a rough order-of-magnitude estimate of what their service may cost for the proposed concept. Please visit our Implementation Partner (IP) portal, where each IP presents an overview of their capabilities to enable a quick assessment of which one may best fit the needs of the project.
Will the requested funding for our Implementation Partner go directly to them, or will it be distributed to the PI and then transferred using a service agreement, etc.? It is unclear to me if indirects can be requested? This becomes particularly important if the funds for the Implementation Partner are distributed to us.
Total funding set aside for this NLRA is approximately $1 million, with an expectation to make up to four awards. CASIS funding is to be allocated to support Implementation Partner costs only. CASIS will execute task orders and/or subcontracts directly with the Implementation Partner on behalf of the awarded principal investigator. No funding will be granted to cover the offeror’s internal costs. Requesting funding for cost elements not covered by this NLRA is grounds for disqualification. CASIS reserves the right to refuse award if no meritorious offers are received.
Is working with multiple Implementation Partners more advantageous than working with a single Implementation Partner?
This decision will be made by the offeror and their project team. CASIS recommends that the PI select the Implementation Partner(s) that provide the best fit for addressing the projected scientific and/or technological requirements for the payload. The operational and technical feasibility evaluation will assess how well the proposed technical solution and concept of operations are addressed by the PI team and their selected Implementation Partner(s). Technical solutions may be designed and executed by teaming with a single or multiple Implementation Partners, but this decision will be made by the principal investigator and the proposing team, not by CASIS.
